Switch from Circle to Who's In
Circle is community-platform-first — strong on forums + courses, light on in-person tools like QR check-in. Its plans run $89–$419/mo billed annually. Move to Who's In Clubs at $10/mo, or $99 billed annually flat — built for real-world clubs and member organisations.
Starter and Growth plans, each with a 14-day free trial.
Why clubs switch from Circle
Plan prices climb from $89 to $419 a month
Circle includes unlimited members, but its plans run from $89/mo (Professional) to $419/mo (Scale), billed annually, plus a 0.5–2% transaction fee by plan. Activity scores start on Business ($199/mo), and Circle Plus is a custom quote.
Who's In Clubs is $10/mo, or $99 billed annually flat for up to 99 members. Past that, Growth ($19/mo, or $190 billed annually) covers unlimited members at one flat price. Every core feature is on both plans; Growth adds unlimited members and day-3 and day-7 follow-up emails for new members.
Forum-first, light on in-person club tools
Circle is strong on forums, member directory, and courses. Its events have recurring series and RSVP caps, but no documented waitlist, no family plans and no membership pause.
Who's In Clubs is built for real-world clubs and associations: recurring events, fixture lists, member-only sessions, dues collection via Stripe Connect with auto-renewal, dunning sequences, family plans.
No native member ID + check-in flow
Circle doesn't have Wallet passes or check-in for in-person meetups.
Who's In Clubs gives every member a Wallet pass member ID, QR check-in at meetups and events, and capacity caps with automatic waitlists.
Step 1: Export from Circle
Get your data out
Export member directory
In Circle admin, navigate to Members > Export > CSV. Captures name, email, member tier, joined date, custom profile fields.
Document community structure
Spaces > Document. Take screenshots or note your forum / channel structure for replication in Who's In Clubs (or a paired forum tool).
Export upcoming events
Events > Upcoming > Export. Captures event title, date, registered members.
Document membership tiers + pricing
Membership Tiers > Document. Each tier with pricing, renewal terms, gated content for replication.
Export courses + content
If you have courses, document them. Circle has native courses; Who's In Clubs doesn't — pair with Teachable / Thinkific / Kajabi for course delivery if needed.
Step 2: Set up on Who's In
Get running in minutes
Create your Who's In Clubs
Sign up at whos-in.app/clubs. Add organisation name and branding.
Configure membership tiers
Recreate your tier hierarchy with pricing + renewal terms. Family plan support included.
Import member directory
Members > Import. Upload Circle CSV. Map name, email, tier, custom fields. Members get Wallet pass.
Set up dues collection + Stripe Connect
Monthly / annual dues through your own Stripe account, with a 0% Who's In fee. Auto-renewal, dunning sequences, lapse-handling.
Recreate upcoming events
For each event, set name, date, time, location, member-tier-gated access. Capacity caps + waitlists.
Pair with Discourse / Discord for forums
Who's In Clubs is real-world-club-first. For forum / discussion threads, pair with Discourse (free for nonprofits) or Discord, and link to it from your club page.
Feature Mapping: Circle to Who's In
| Circle Feature | Who's In Equivalent |
|---|---|
| $89–$419/mo billed annually | Flat $99/yr up to 99 members, $190/yr unlimited |
| Forum / spaces (excellent) | Pair with Discourse / Discord |
| Member directory | Member directory + Wallet pass |
| Events with RSVP caps (no check-in) | Real-world events + check-in + capacity |
| Native courses | Pair with Teachable / Thinkific |
| Paid memberships (0.5–2% transaction fee) | Full dues + dunning + auto-renewal |
| Member feed | No equivalent (broadcast messaging via email) |
| Live streams | No live streaming (Conference can share your stream link) |
| Branded mobile app | Branded PWA included |
| No Wallet pass member ID | Wallet pass member ID + QR check-in |
| Integrations | CSV exports of members and attendees |
| Community-first | Real-world-club-first |
Total migration time: ~4-6 hours
Most clubs complete their migration in a single sitting. No technical skills required.
Migration FAQ
Ready to switch from Circle?
Start your 14-day free trial and migrate in under ~4-6 hours.
14-day free trial on every paid plan.